- Public allowed to see video evidence in France mass rape trial
- Revenge for Medvedev, Tsitsipas at Shanghai Masters
- US hiring soars past expectations in sign of resilient market
- Under-fire Ten Hag 'together' with Man Utd hierarchy
- Guardiola talks of Man City love affair as financial hearing rumbles on
- De Bruyne out of Belgium Nations League squad
- Japanese trainer Yahagi hopes Shin Emperor achieves 50-year-old Arc dream
- UK's Starmer hails 'landmark' carbon capture funding
- As EU targets Chinese cars, European rivals sputter
- Bosnia floods kill 14 people
- Tennis world number one Swiatek splits with coach Wiktorowski
- Liverpool share responsibility for Nunez goal drought, says Slot
- Top EU court finds against FIFA in key transfer market ruling
- Oil extends gains, Hong Kong stocks resume rally
- Top seed Sabalenka stunned by Muchova in Beijing last eight
- Khamenei says Iran's allies 'will not back down' in war with Israel
- Tsitsipas gets revenge against Nishikori at Shanghai Masters
- 'Alone against world': lawyer defending Frenchman in mass rape trial
- 'A man provides': Ukrainian miners send families away as Russia advances
- EU states greenlight extra tariffs on EVs from China
- Singapore charges hotel tycoon in case linked to jailed minister
- India asks top court to heed marital rape leniency
- S. Korean director brings fresh film adaptation to Busan festival
- Hong Kong stocks bounce as Middle East fears boost crude again
- Blood and blades as Thailand celebrates vegetarian festival
- Binder tops Japan MotoGP practice with Martin third
- Hong Kong stocks resume rally, oil dips after Middle East-fuelled surge
- Lebanon says Israeli strike cuts off main road to Syria
- India asks top court not to toughen marital rape penalties
- Sinner not 'comfortable' as doping case clouds Shanghai campaign
- Brazilians choose mayors, councillors in bellwether election
- Japan PM warns 'today's Ukraine could be tomorrow's East Asia'
- Portugal looks to put new twist on cork industry
- Spoon scratching: Kenya's DIY DJ
- Lyon's Matavesi calls for change after 'crazy' World Cup salary strike threat
- Israel bombards Beirut after deadliest West Bank strike in decades
- North Korea's Kim threatens to use nukes if attacked
- Taiwan cleans up after Typhoon Krathon batters south
- Bayern look to rebound at bogey side Frankfurt
- Finally beaten Madrid aiming for Villarreal rebound in La Liga
- Crude stable after Israel-Iran surge, Hong Kong stocks resume gains
- Bagnaia leads Martin in first Japan MotoGP practice
- Bolivia's Morales investigated for rape of a minor: minister
- Former Wallaby O'Connor signs for Canterbury Crusaders
- Ipswich Town's Luongo enticed back to Socceroos under new coach Popovic
- Three US police convicted in connection with beating death of Black man
- Iran's Khamenei to give rare Friday sermon after attack on Israel
- EU court set for key Diarra ruling which could shake up transfer market
- Taliban's battle with IS opens door to foreign cooperation
- More than AI misinformation, US voters worry about lying politicians
RBGPF | 100% | 58.93 | $ | |
CMSC | -0.16% | 24.74 | $ | |
CMSD | -0.16% | 24.89 | $ | |
SCS | -1.98% | 12.62 | $ | |
BCC | -0.9% | 138.29 | $ | |
GSK | -2.81% | 38.37 | $ | |
AZN | -2.12% | 77.93 | $ | |
RIO | -1.42% | 69.83 | $ | |
BTI | -2.45% | 35.11 | $ | |
NGG | -2.7% | 66.97 | $ | |
RYCEF | 1.15% | 6.98 | $ | |
RELX | -1.46% | 46.61 | $ | |
BCE | -1.77% | 33.84 | $ | |
JRI | -0.6% | 13.3 | $ | |
VOD | -0.52% | 9.69 | $ | |
BP | 0.28% | 32.46 | $ |
Top EU court finds against FIFA in key transfer market ruling
The EU's top court said on Friday some international football rules regulating player transfers are contrary to the bloc's laws, in a landmark decision that could shake up the system.
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) was called on to decide a long-running dispute between former French footballer Lassana Diarra and FIFA, over what happens when players unilaterally terminate their contract.
In a highly anticipated verdict, judges found that by restricting a footballers' ability to seek further employment, current FIFA rules hinder the EU's free movement and competition between clubs.
"The Court holds that all of those rules are contrary to EU law," it said.
The ruling could have far-reaching implications for the lucrative transfer market, allowing players to leave their club without fear of being legally trapped afterwards.
"In a way, the Lassana Diarra affair is the Bosman 2.0 affair," Diarra's Belgian lawyer Jean-Louis Dupont, said ahead of the judgement, predicting the "end" of the current system in case of a favourable verdict.
Dupont was also involved in the 1995 case of footballer Jean-Marc Bosman, which allowed players to move to another club at the end of their contract without a transfer fee being paid and also ended quotas on foreign players at clubs.
On Friday, he hailed the new ruling as "a total victory".
- Ten-year saga -
The Diarra saga goes back 10 years.
In August 2014, Lokomotiv terminated the midfielder's contract citing contractual breaches by the player. The Russian club also sought 20 million euros ($22m) compensation from Diarra.
Diarra, now 39, refused and requested that Lokomotiv pay him compensation.
He was eventually ordered to pay his former club 10 million euros by FIFA, a fine that was upheld by the Court of Arbitration for Sport. Diarra also received a backdated 15-month suspension.
According to FIFA regulations, if a player terminates his contract unilaterally and "without just cause", he must pay compensation which includes his remuneration and benefits until the end of his contract.
Additionally, a purchasing club could be held jointly liable for any compensation and, in certain cases, be banned from signing any new players for a given period.
National football associations are also forced to refuse to issue a certificate needed to complete a transfer while a dispute is pending.
As a result clubs were not rushing to recruit Diarra after he left Lokomotiv.
His lawyers argued the rules violated the EU's free movement of workers, and by limiting the ability of clubs to recruit, were contrary to the principle of free competition within the 27-nation bloc.
Diarra requested six million euros from FIFA, on the grounds that he was prevented from playing during most of the 2014-2015 season.
Belgian side Charleroi rescinded their contract offer, afraid of the possible legal and financial consequences.
- Considerable risk -
After several twists and turns, a Belgian court asked the CJEU its opinion on the matter.
On Friday, the CJEU found that the rules impede the free movement of players by "imposing considerable legal risks, unforeseeable and potentially very high financial risks as well as major sporting risks on those players and clubs wishing to employ them".
Although some restrictions could be justified to allow a certain degree of stability in the player rosters of football clubs, the rules in question went beyond "what is necessary to pursue that objective", it said.
Judges said the burden put on purchasing clubs had as object the restriction, and even prevention, of cross-border competition, and as such did "not appear to be indispensable or necessary".
The ruling throws the world of football transfers into uncertainty.
Smaller teams often rely on trading players to sustain their finances -- recruiting young prospects on the cheap to later sell them at a high price.
Clubs currently have no obligation to let players go before the end of their contract, which gives management power in transfer negotiations, a lever they seem to stand to lose.
Capped 34 times by France, Diarra also played for Chelsea, Arsenal, Portsmouth and Real Madrid before ending his career at Paris Saint-Germain in 2019.
G.Schulte--BTB